Our research cited by
Hire a Multifamily Feasibility Study Consultant
MMCG Invest prepares an independent, lender ready feasibility study for your SBA, USDA or bank loan file, signed by the principal, Michal Mohelsky, J.D., FMVA.
- From $4,900
- 9 to 16 business days
- Rush delivery is available from 5 business days
- Payment: 50 percent at engagement and 50 percent on delivery
- Written acceptance guarantee: any revision the lender or agency requires is made at no additional cost
- Track record: $2.3 billion construction cost analyzed and $1.7 billion loan amount, January 1 to September 1, 2026
- (628) 225-1110
Committee rules that set the numbers in a California apartment deal
A market study no older than 180 days, signed by an analyst with no identity of interest
Section 10322 of the CTCAC regulations requires a full market study prepared or updated within 180 days of the filing deadline by an independent third party having no identity of interest with the development's partners, intended partners or any other member of the Development Team (1). The study must meet the market study guidelines distributed by the committee and establish both need and demand for the project; where it does not, the application may be considered ineligible to receive Tax Credits and may be disqualified (1). The guidelines, issued jointly by CTCAC and CDLAC and read here in the text dated December 2024, apply to every applicant for tax-exempt bond authority or housing tax credits irrespective of project size and location, put the study at the expense of the developer, and require a signed letter certifying the dates of the report and of the site inspection, that no identity of interest exists, and how many market studies and physical inspections the analyst has done in the project's primary market area (3).
CDLAC keeps a clock of its own for bond deals. Under Section 5107 the study is prepared within 180 days of the application deadline and must be updated when proposed rents change by more than five percent, when the distribution of higher rents increases by more than 5 percent, or when 180 days have elapsed between the earliest site inspection of the subject or a comparable property and the application deadline of the round (2). CDLAC shall not accept an updated market study when more than twelve months have passed since the earliest listed site inspection date, and the applicant then provides a new study (2). The guidelines add that the matrices must be updated if the proposed rents in the application change by any amount (3). A memorandum of October 30, 2026 proposed, for calendar year 2027, that the analyst also certify that the site inspection is within two years of the application deadline; the draft set November 23, 2026 as its deadline for written comment, and this page states the guidelines of December 2024 (3), not the draft (11).
Both sets of regulations are read here in the versions dated December 10, 2025 (1)(2). CDLAC's regulations page, as we read it in November 2026, listed proposed regulations under the heading December 9, 2026 Proposed Regulations, which we did not read, so the CDLAC rules on this page are those of the December 10, 2025 text (23). We did not read the California statutes those regulations cite, so this page reports what the regulation texts say and does not state what the codes provide.
Each affordable rent at least 10 percent below the comparable market rent
CTCAC's basic threshold on housing need and demand, Section 10325(f)(1), asks for a market study showing that the proposed tenant paid rents for each affordable unit type will be at least 10 percent below the weighted average rent for the same unit types in comparable market rate rental properties, and that the proposed unit value ratio, stated as dollars per square foot, will be no more than the weighted average for comparable market rate units (1). In rural areas without sufficient three and four bedroom market rate comparables, the affordable rents must be at least 20 percent below the rents for single family homes (1). The regulation calls meeting these tests essential and adds that meeting them will not in itself show adequate need and demand (1). CDLAC writes the same 10 percent test for each Restricted Rental Unit type of a bond deal, and also requires each Restricted Rental Unit's value ratio, in dollars per square foot, to be at or below the weighted average unit value ratio for comparable market rate units, both demonstrated in a Rent Comparability Matrix (2). Section 5107(a)(2) exempts from both a project subject to an existing Residential Rental Regulatory Agreement that proposes tenant paid rents and income targeting not exceeding 105 percent of the current ones and operates with a vacancy rate of no more than 5 percent, or 10 percent for single room occupancy and special needs housing (2).
In a memorandum dated October 9, 2026 CTCAC noticed proposed regulation changes for adoption at its meeting scheduled for December 9, 2026, one of which proposed to remove the unit value ratio test from Section 10325(f)(1); the memorandum took written comment until 5:00 p.m. on November 2, 2026, and we did not read the outcome (10). The test stated above is the text of December 10, 2025 (1), and CDLAC's Section 5107(a)(2) and the December 2024 guidelines print the unit value ratio in their own texts (2)(3).
Comparables are drawn from within one mile, at least three to a matrix
The guidelines call for at least three market-rate rental properties within one mile of the subject property, or within the primary market area where none exist within one mile, and tell the analyst to choose the projects closest to the subject over projects of similar age and amenities that are more distant (3). A separate rent comparability matrix is completed for each unit type, for market rate and for affordable comparables, and each matrix must include three or more comparable projects within one mile unless the analyst certifies that fewer exist (3); the one mile comparable set of a California study is built by the steps in our methodology. For new construction the study must also state that the sites number no more than five and all lie within a 1 mile diameter circle within the same county (3).
Lease-up is a fixed schedule: six months, or twelve above 150 units and for senior projects
The demand shown in a CTCAC study must appear strong enough to reach stabilized occupancy, which the regulation sets at 90 percent for Special Needs projects and 95 percent for all other projects, within six months of being placed in service for projects of 150 units or less, and within 12 months for projects of more than 150 units and for senior projects (1). The guidelines restate the schedule by housing type: SRO and Special Needs projects 90 percent occupied within six months, Large Family projects 95 percent occupied within six months, each with one year where the property is over 150 units, and all Senior projects 95 percent occupied within 1 year (3). The analyst must calculate a capture rate for each income limit and a penetration rate, and the guidelines we read attach no numeric ceiling to either (3).
The guidelines fix the demand inputs and name seven counties for commuter demand
In calculating demand the analyst assumes that market rate households will spend up to 30 percent of their income for gross rent and lower income households up to 40 percent, and for senior projects may assume up to 50 percent (3). Only the demand from the primary market area is considered in showing adequate demand, unless surveys of initial move-in renters at similar projects support an estimate of the renters moving in from outside it (3). The guidelines name seven counties, Santa Clara, San Mateo, San Francisco, Marin, Contra Costa, Alameda and Santa Cruz, where high incomes, high housing costs and a low renter base are prevalent, and for market areas of that kind the analyst may add demand from households whose wage earners commute in, counting only commute distances in excess of 8 miles; committee staff are the final arbiter of whether that model is appropriate (3).
Underwriting rates are printed in Section 10327
The 15-year pro forma must use a 2.5 percent increase in gross income, a 3.5 percent increase in operating expenses and a 2 percent increase in property taxes, although CTCAC accepts a 2 percent income and 3 percent operating expense assumption where a private conventional lender and the project's equity partner use it (1). For projects with a HUD rental subsidy that will receive a subsidy layering review from CTCAC, CTCAC accepts 2 percent income growth, 3 percent operating expense growth and 7 percent vacancy (1). Vacancy and collection loss is 10 percent for special needs units and non-special needs SRO units without a significant project-based public rental subsidy, unless waived by the Executive Director on vacancy data in the market area for the population to be served, between 5 and 10 percent where those units have such a subsidy, and 5 percent for all other units (1). In the coverage figures supplied to CDLAC the applicant uses the market area vacancy rate or the appraised vacancy rate, and the regulation says in no event less than 5 percent but also requires a written explanation with the application where less than 5 percent is used (2).
An initial debt service coverage ratio of at least 1.15 to 1 in at least one of the project's first three years is required, except for FHA/HUD projects, RHS projects and projects financed with hard debt by the California Housing Finance Agency (1). The regulation also sets a ceiling: cash flow after debt service is limited to the higher of 25 percent of the anticipated annual must pay debt service payment or 8 percent of gross income during each of the first three years of operation, with exceptions that include projects in which less than 50 percent of the units are Tax Credit Units (1).
Operating expenses, including those of manager units and market rate units, must at least equal the minimum operating expense standards the committee staff publish annually by region and project type, and the Executive Director may use expenses up to 15 percent less when the equity investor and the permanent lender are in place and have agreed to them (1). A draft dated October 30, 2026 proposed 2027 minimums computed at 90 percent of the mean for each region and housing type, the minimums having last been updated in 2022, with increases between analyses by core CPI of never less than 2.0 percent and never more than 5.0 percent in a single year (12). The draft set November 23, 2026 as its deadline for comments, and its figures are not stated here as the standard (12).
Reserves, the developer fee and the builder's 14 percent
The minimum replacement reserve deposit is $300 per unit per year, or $250 per unit per year for new construction or senior projects, and the operating reserve is funded at three months of estimated operating expenses and debt service under stabilized occupancy (1). Builder overhead, profit and general requirements are held to an overall limitation of 14 percent of the cost of construction, and project developers may not enter into fixed-price contracts that do not account for it (1).
For a 9 percent new construction, rehabilitation only or adaptive reuse application the developer fee that may be included in project costs and eligible basis is the lesser of 15 percent of the project's unadjusted eligible basis, together with 15 percent of the pro rata basis for non-residential costs, or $2,500,000, and $2,800,000 for a project that restricts the greater of 15 Low-Income Units or 25 percent of the Low-Income Units for Special Needs Populations; acquisition/rehabilitation applications use a separate basis formula (1). For a 4 percent bond application of the same three types the maximum fee is the sum of those two 15 percent amounts, but all developer fees above the greater of 15 percent of unadjusted eligible basis up to $2,500,000, or $1,000,000 plus 5 percent of that basis in excess of $6,666,667, must be deferred or contributed as equity to the project, the figures being $2,800,000 and 7 percent under the Special Needs restriction (1). For 4 percent applications, effective through December 31, 2028, any developer fee in excess of $6,000,000 is deferred or contributed as equity, and the committee is to meet before that date to discuss the application of any developer fee above that amount (1). The regulation raises the 15 percent and the $2,500,000 of the 4 percent rule to 20 percent and $3,000,000 for projects that receive general partner experience under CDLAC Section 5105(f)(1)(B) (1), a fee CTCAC's memorandum of October 9, 2026 proposed to reform into a Joint Venture fee (10).
Threshold basis limits cap the credit by county and bedroom count
At application CTCAC limits the unadjusted eligible basis used to calculate the maximum amount of Tax Credits to the amounts published on its website, and at placed in service to the higher of the amount in effect at application or for the year the project places in service (1). The memorandum of January 21, 2026 that issues the 2026 limits draws them from a five-year data set of projects awarded from 2021 to 2025 and a region-level basis limit (6). For a two bedroom unit it prints $965,600 in San Francisco, $608,800 in Los Angeles and $449,600 in each of Fresno and San Joaquin counties (6). The regulation raises the limits by 20 percent for a development that is paid for in whole or in part out of public funds and is subject to a legal requirement to pay state or federal prevailing wages on the entire project, and by an additional 5 percent where the project certifies a project labor agreement or a skilled and trained workforce (1). These are the committee's caps on basis, not estimates of construction cost.
Local land use approvals must be in hand on the filing date
Section 10325(f)(4) requires evidence, at the time the application is filed, that the project as proposed is zoned for the intended use and has obtained all applicable local land use approvals that allow the discretion of local elected officials to be applied, except that an appeal period may run 30 days beyond the application due date (1). The regulation counts general plan amendments, rezonings and conditional use permits as such approvals and leaves out design review, variances and development agreements (1). A project that qualifies for by right or ministerial approval may instead submit confirmation of its eligibility from HCD's Housing Accountability Unit or a third-party attorney letter, and bond applicants are held to the same section (1). This page states no approval timeline under the state's housing statutes, which we did not read.
A bond award: 30 percent of basis, 55 years of restrictions and a deposit that can be lost
Private activity bond awards made after Round 2 of 2025 cannot exceed 30 percent of the aggregated depreciable basis plus land basis, and the Executive Director may grant up to 40 percent where the project's permanent financing supports the larger award and the project is unable to obtain recycled bonds from the applicant; awards made in or before that round were limited to 55 percent (2). At least 10 percent of the units must have gross rents restricted to households with incomes no greater than 50 percent of area median income, and the Qualified Project Period is 55 years from the date on which 50 percent occupancy is achieved (2). The performance deposit is one-half of one percent of the allocation requested, not to exceed $100,000, evidenced within 20 calendar days following an award for a residential rental project, and a pro rata portion is forfeited if less than 80 percent of the allocation is used to issue bonds (2).
Readiness is scored and then enforced. A project may earn 10 points by documenting enforceable financing commitments and demonstrating that construction can begin within 180 days, 201 days or 222 days of the bond allocation, as assigned by the Executive Director, and before that deadline CDLAC must receive, among other items, an executed construction contract and issued building permits (2). The bond issuance deadline in the committee resolution is no later than December 31 of the year following the year of the allocation (2).
State credits for bond deals are a separate pool with caps of its own
The committee's allocation table for 2026, updated September 2, 2026, lists State Tax Credits Available in 2026 of $500,000,000 for new construction 4 percent projects, and a Total State Tax Credit Available in 2026 of $515,531,071 once returned and carried forward credits are added (4). Of that, $25,000,000 is the general allocation for farmworker housing and $100,000,000 is listed for the California Housing Finance Agency's Mixed-Income Program, with $99,918,453 awarded in Round 2 (4). The regulation allows an amount up to $200,000,000 in a calendar year for housing financed by that programme that also receives a bond allocation from CDLAC, a ceiling above the figure in the 2026 table (1)(4). Within a funding round, and excluding the $25,000,000 for farmworker housing, the regulation also caps the share of the available state credits that each bond pool may take, at 15 percent for the BIPOC Project Pool, 15 percent for the Rural Project Pool, 25 percent for the Homeless Project Set Aside and 20 percent for the ELI/VLI Project Set Aside of the New Construction Pool, the last of which may be exceeded by the amount of state credits remaining in the Homeless Project Set Aside (1). CTCAC's memorandum of October 9, 2026 proposed to replace the BIPOC Project Pool in that list with an Emerging Developer Pool, as a conforming change to proposed CDLAC regulations (10).
Property tax: reappraisal at purchase or construction, and the welfare exemption filings
Rule 461 of the State Board of Equalization opens by stating that Section 2 of article XIII A of the California Constitution provides, with certain exceptions, that real property shall be reappraised if purchased, newly constructed or a change in ownership occurs after the original base year, and the rule directs the assessor to carry the base year value appropriately indexed or the current lien date full value, whichever is less (9). CTCAC's underwriting sets its own property tax expense minimum at 1 percent of total replacement cost unless the verified tax rate is higher or lower, the sponsorship includes an identified 501(c)(3) corporate general partner which will pursue a property tax exemption, or the sponsorship includes a Tribe or tribally-designated housing entity (1).
Under the Board's Rule 140 a qualifying claimant, which includes a limited partnership in which the managing general partner is an eligible nonprofit corporation or an eligible limited liability company, must receive low-income housing tax credits or government financing for the property and hold a recorded deed restriction or a recorded regulatory agreement (7). The exemption equals the percentage of the value of the property that is continuously available to or occupied by lower income households at the prescribed rents, is based on the actual use of the property, and includes the units reserved for the resident property manager (7). Until the regulatory agreement is finalized and recorded, the Preliminary Reservation Letter from CTCAC or the CDLAC Bond Cap Allocation Letter is acceptable (7). A claimant other than such a limited partnership may instead rely on another legal document that restricts a minimum of 90 percent of the units, and is then limited to $20,000,000 in assessed value across its properties (7). The rule's history shows its last amendment as effective January 29, 2020; we did not check for later amendments (7).
Rule 140.2 adds a state filing ahead of the county claim. The limited partnership files with the State Board of Equalization an application for a Supplemental Clearance Certificate for each low-income housing property, which may be granted only if the managing general partner has already been granted an Organizational Clearance Certificate, and the general partners certify under penalty of perjury that funds that would have been necessary to pay property taxes are used to maintain the affordability of, or reduce rents for, the units occupied by lower income households (8). A copy of the certificate goes in with the welfare exemption claim filed with the assessor of the county in which the property is located (8).
The residual insurer's limits for commercial habitational buildings
The Insurance Commissioner's Stipulation and Order No. 2026-1, dated February 27, 2026, promulgated a revised Plan of Operation for the California FAIR Plan Association (21). The order sets the maximum limit of liability for Division I commercial property policies placed through the plan at $20 million per structure, with a total aggregate limit of $100 million per Location, and the plan's reporting rules list commercial habitational buildings among the categories of commercial property policies (21). Policies with a limit over $20 million per Location are High Value Commercial Property Policies, which the plan shall cease to offer within three years after approval and implementation of the requisite filings; after that Sunset Date commercial policies issue at a maximum policy limit of $20 million per Location (21). The order does not give the calendar date of the Sunset Date, and it adds that the maximum Division I limits are subject to periodic review and may be adjusted as deemed necessary by the Commissioner, and that higher limits of liability also may be placed through the FAIR Plan under written guidelines adopted by a majority of the Governing Committee (21).
California's stock, credit ceilings and 2026 awards in official figures
The Department of Finance's release of May 1, 2026 puts total housing in the state at 15,064,131 units after a net addition of 115,165 units, with new construction adding 56,855 multi-family housing units (18). The department's E-5 table for 1/1/2026 counts 3,697,067 of the state's units in structures of five or more (19). CTCAC's own 2025 Fast Facts show 526 applications received and 253 projects awarded, with 28,429 lower-income households to be assisted (20).
In the bond rounds, CDLAC's final lists show Total Awards of 74 and an allocation of $1,295,593,706 for Round 1, dated June 22, 2026, and Total Awards of 83 and $1,673,861,582 for Round 2, dated September 1, 2026 (14)(15). In the 9 percent competition, CTCAC's first round final approved recommendations of June 22, 2026 total $27,659,606 of annual federal credits and $32,521,187 of state credits for the set-aside projects, and $14,834,214 and $20,103,339 for the geographic regions (16). The preliminary second round list of October 6, 2026, which states that it is not binding on CTCAC, shows $29,181,213 and $30,640,464 for the set-aside projects, $37,580,521 and $45,423,930 for the regions (17).
CTCAC's estimate for 2026, updated September 2, 2026, puts the Total Federal Credit Ceiling at $136,381,450, made up of $134,437,736 of population based credits at $3.416 per capita on a population of 39,355,309 plus $1,943,714 of returned and surplus credits (4). Step 4 of the same table, its state credit ceiling calculation, puts the Total State Tax Credit Available for 2026 at $67,256,563, which is $129,574,757 less $62,318,194 of advance allocations in the prior year; 15 percent of it, $10,088,484, is set aside for 4 percent projects and $57,168,079 is the balance for 9 percent projects (4). The regulations set aside 10 percent of the federal ceiling for projects of qualified nonprofit organizations, 20 percent for rural areas, 5 percent for At-Risk projects and 4 percent for Special Needs projects and, after deducting the federal credits set aside under Section 10315(a) through (g), apportion the credit by region in approximately the shares the regulation lists, from 17.6 percent for the City of Los Angeles and 17.2 percent for the balance of Los Angeles County down to 3.7 percent for San Francisco County, with 8.6 percent for the Central Valley Region, which includes San Joaquin County (1). CDLAC's Exhibit A, updated as of September 14, 2026, prints a 2026 State Ceiling of $5,312,966,715 in its Total column and $4,772,966,715 in its QRRP column, for qualified residential rental projects (5).
The California sequence, from entitlement to bond issuance
- Entitlement. Zoning and the discretionary local approvals are complete when the application is filed, with at most a 30 day appeal period still running (1).
- Market study. The report is prepared or updated within 180 days of the filing deadline, and for a bond deal it is updated if more than 180 days separate the earliest site inspection from the round's deadline and replaced by a new study once more than twelve months have passed since that inspection (1)(2). A California round missed by more than those limits means an update or a new report, a fee our feasibility study cost page explains.
- Application rounds. For 2026 the 9 percent applications were due by 5 p.m. on April 7, 2026 and July 21, 2026, and the joint bond and credit applications on February 3, 2026, May 19, 2026 and September 8, 2026 (13). We did not read a 2027 calendar.
- Filing fees. A competitive application carries a filing fee of $2,500, with an additional $1,000 for each additional Local Reviewing Agency, and a bond filing carries a CDLAC $1,500 application fee and a CTCAC $1,500 application fee, $1,700 for scattered site and resyndication projects, paid preferably online or, if mailed, by separate checks sent together to the CDLAC office (1)(13). CTCAC's memorandum of October 9, 2026 proposed to change the application fee structure for scattered site projects (10).
- Review of a bond application. CTCAC may require up to 60 days to review an application and an additional 30 days to consider it for a reservation, and applicants must deliver applications no less than 90 days before the committee meeting at which they want a decision (1).
- After a 9 percent reservation. The allocation fee is 4 percent of the first year's federal credit reserved and the performance deposit 4 percent, not to exceed $100,000; for an applicant that did not receive maximum points in the Readiness to Proceed category, an updated application is due no later than 180 days or 194 days, as applicable, after the reservation and construction must start no later than 12 months after it, and failure to start within 12 months may result in rescission of the reservation (1).
- After a bond award. The CTCAC reservation fee is 1 percent of the annual federal credit reserved, due within 20 days of the bond reservation; the CDLAC deposit, the construction start and the December 31 issuance deadline follow the rules above (1)(2).
- Welfare exemption. The Supplemental Clearance Certificate is obtained from the Board of Equalization and filed with the claim to the county assessor (8).
How 9 percent credits, bonds, HUD and USDA loans meet the committee rules
The 9 percent competition. Awards to an individual, entity, affiliates and related entities are limited to no more than four per competitive round, and no one general partner or related party will be awarded more than 15 percent of the Federal Credit Ceiling in a calendar year unless that would prevent allocation of all the available credit (1). Where applications tie on points, the regulation's tie breakers apply: in the single-jurisdiction competitions of San Francisco and the City of Los Angeles the first is a formal letter of support from the San Francisco Mayor's Office of Housing or the Los Angeles Housing Department, and statewide a non-rural new construction Large Family project receives a tiebreaker bonus of 20 percentage points in a Highest Resource census tract and 10 in a High Resource tract, which stops once the round's Large Family New Construction goal for such projects is met and is withheld in some cases, including certain projects supported by affordable housing ordinances (1). What the federal credit rules ask of the report is on our LIHTC market study page.
Bonds with 4 percent credits. CDLAC's Exhibit A divides the 2026 residential rental ceiling into pools: $1,000,000,000 for Acquisition and Rehabilitation, $130,000,000 each for the BIPOC and the Rural new construction pools, $650,000,000 for the new construction Homeless set aside, $780,000,000 for ELI/VLI, $310,000,000 for State Funded Mixed Income and $1,749,424,098 in new construction geographic apportionments (5). The regulations hold the Rural Project Pool to no more than 10 percent of the total pool (2). The California Housing Finance Agency's 2026 term sheet limits the Mixed-Income Program subsidy loan to the lesser of $6 million, $50,000 per regulated unit, with up to $10,000 more per unit in Highest or High Resource areas, or 50 percent of the permanent loan amount, at 3 percent simple interest (22). How state credits and a subordinate loan of that size alter a capital stack is covered on our affordable housing feasibility study page.
HUD-insured loans. CTCAC exempts FHA/HUD projects from its 1.15 to 1 coverage minimum (1), and CDLAC runs an open application process for projects assisted by HUD: a CDLAC Forward Commitment letter may be granted in lieu of an award of allocation until the applicant receives the HUD Firm Commitment letter, applications may be submitted at any time with an expected staff review period of at least 30 days, a MAP Lender commitment letter outlining the FHA financing accompanies the application, and proof that the HUD Firm Commitment application was submitted is due within 30 days of the forward commitment (2). Of the items on this page, two reach a market rate California building with a HUD-insured loan and no credits or bonds: reappraisal as Rule 461 describes it (9), and the FAIR Plan's maximum for Division I commercial property policies, which the Commissioner's order of February 27, 2026 sets at $20 million per structure and $100 million per Location, subject to adjustment by the Commissioner (21). The federal programme is on our HUD multifamily market study page.
USDA Section 515 and Section 538. CTCAC's rural set-aside takes 20 percent of the Federal Credit Ceiling, and an area is eligible under the Section 515 programme if it is on the Section 515 designated places list in effect the prior September 30 or is so designated in writing by the USDA Multifamily Housing Program Director (1). Within the rural set-aside, 14 percent is available first to new construction projects with a funding commitment from the Rural Housing Service of at least $1,000,000 under its Section 514 or Section 515 programme, or a reservation of at least $1,000,000 in HOME or CDBG-DR funding, and RHS projects are exempt from the 1.15 to 1 coverage minimum (1). The federal rules for both programmes are on our USDA multifamily page.
Mixed-use buildings. CTCAC's developer fee limit reaches the commercial part of a building, counting 15 percent of the basis for non-residential costs allocated on a pro rata basis (1). Section 10327(g)(7) keeps the two parts apart in underwriting: residential income may not support any negative cash flow of the commercial portion and commercial income may not support the residential portion (1); where that commercial portion carries its own SBA or USDA guaranteed loan, the reference is SOP 50 10 8.1 or 7 CFR Part 5001.
The tests a California study has to pass, and how we run them
- Study date. The report date and every site inspection date against CTCAC's 180 days and CDLAC's twelve month limit (1)(2).
- Rent comparison. A matrix for each unit type with three or more comparables inside one mile, each affordable rent at least 10 percent under the weighted average market rent, and each unit's value ratio at or below the weighted average for comparable market rate units, as Section 10325(f)(1), CDLAC's Section 5107(a)(2) and the December 2024 guidelines print it (1)(2)(3).
- Lease-up. Months to 95 percent occupancy, or 90 percent for Special Needs, against the six month or 12 month schedule (1).
- Demand. Income bands at up to 30 percent of income for gross rent for market rate households and up to 40 percent for lower income households, or up to 50 percent for senior projects, and demand from the primary market area unless move-in surveys at similar projects support demand from outside it (3).
- DSCR. At least 1.15 to 1 in one of the first three years on CTCAC's 2.5, 3.5 and 2 percent growth rates and its 5 or 10 percent vacancy and collection loss, with cash flow tested against the 25 percent and 8 percent ceiling (1).
- Break-even. Break-even occupancy is stated with operating expenses at the committee's published minimum for the region and the $250 or $300 reserve deposit (1).
- Property tax. Two cases: 1 percent of total replacement cost, and the welfare exemption with the Board of Equalization certificate in place (1)(8).
- Basis and bonds. Eligible basis against the county's threshold basis limit with and without the 20 percent prevailing wage increase, and the bond request against 30 percent of aggregated depreciable basis plus land basis (1)(2).
- Insurance. For a property insured above $20 million per Location, the premium case with FAIR Plan cover held to that limit after the Sunset Date, beside the order's clause that the limits may be adjusted (21).
- Model study. Section 515 Preservation in San Joaquin, California is a model study of a Section 515 preservation in San Joaquin.
California jobs and building permits, and the San Francisco, Oakland and Hayward rent index, for multifamily, autumn 2026
MMCG Invest is a multifamily feasibility study consultant for borrowers, lenders and CDCs. A California apartment study reads the state's labor market before it turns to the committee tests. California's unemployment rate was 5.1 percent in September 2026, unchanged from August (California Employment Development Department, news release of October 16, 2026).
Total nonfarm payroll jobs were 18,151,600 in September 2026. They rose by 129,300, or 0.72 percent, from September 2025, against a national gain of 0.31 percent over the same year (California Employment Development Department, news release of October 16, 2026).
Building permits authorized 9,329 housing units of all structure types in California in September 2026, not seasonally adjusted, against 9,275 in September 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, October 27, 2026). Construction employment in the state was 883.8 thousand in September 2026, seasonally adjusted, against 888.6 thousand a year earlier (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, October 20, 2026).
The Census Bureau's population estimate for California is 39,355,309 for 2025 against 39,364,774 for 2024, a decline between the two estimates (U.S. Census Bureau, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, March 3, 2026).
The consumer price index for rent of primary residence in the San Francisco, Oakland and Hayward metro area was 535.176 in September 2026, not seasonally adjusted. It was 521.377 in September 2025 (U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, November 10, 2026). A California multifamily feasibility study sets the state readings and this one metro rent index beside the county and primary market area evidence that the rent comparison and the demand count require.
National multifamily starts, rental vacancy and interest rates behind a California apartment study
California projects borrow in national debt markets and lease against a national building cycle. The U.S. rental vacancy rate was 7.6 percent in the third quarter of 2026, not seasonally adjusted. It was 7.3 percent in the second quarter and 7.1 percent in the third quarter of 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau, Housing Vacancies and Homeownership, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, October 28, 2026). The series covers all rental housing, not apartments alone.
Starts in buildings with five units or more ran at a seasonally adjusted annual rate of 349 thousand in September 2026. That compares with 376 thousand in August and 471 thousand in September 2025 (U.S. Census Bureau and HUD, New Residential Construction, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, October 20, 2026). Completions in such buildings were 339 thousand against 426 thousand a year earlier, and units under construction were 677 thousand against 699 thousand, in the same release.
The 10-year Treasury constant maturity yield was 5.10 percent on November 12, 2026, against 4.08 percent on November 12, 2025 (Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, H.15, as published by the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, November 13, 2026). A multifamily feasibility study in California tests debt service at rates of the study date and states that date beside each rate.
USDA Section 538 terms and the 2026 federal tax credit changes for California multifamily
Under the Guaranteed Rural Rental Housing Program rule, the maximum guarantee on a permanent loan is 90 percent unless the Agency announces a different percent in a Federal Register notice (7 CFR 3565.52, January 1, 2026 edition). A guaranteed loan to a for-profit borrower may not exceed the lesser of 90 percent of development costs or 90 percent of the lender's determination of value (7 CFR 3565.204(b), same edition). The percentage is 97 for a nonprofit or a state, local or tribal government body.
Units must be available only to households whose income at initial occupancy does not exceed 115 percent of area median income. A unit's rent, including tenant-paid utilities, may not exceed 30 percent of 115 percent of area median income. The average rent for a project may not exceed 30 percent of 100 percent of area median income (7 CFR 3565.202 and 3565.203, January 1, 2026 edition).
A Rural Housing Service notice published September 25, 2026 raised the maximum loan-to-cost percentage for Section 538 loans under Option Three, the Continuous Guarantee, from 70 percent to 80 percent (91 FR 60930). For the first 200 Section 538 loans closed in the Preservation Pilot that the same notice opens on October 9, 2026, the debt service coverage requirement is reduced to 1.11, from the rule's level of at least 1.15 (7 CFR 3565.303, January 1, 2026 edition). MMCG's model study of USDA Section 538 apartments in Tifton, Georgia is a worked example of a Section 538 loan outside California, not a client engagement.
Public Law 119-21, approved July 4, 2025, added an alternative to the 50 percent tax-exempt bond test for 4 percent credits. Under section 70422(b), a building qualifies where qualifying bonds finance 25 percent or more of the aggregate basis of the building and land. One or more of the obligations must have an issue date after December 31, 2025 and finance at least 5 percent of that basis. The change applies to buildings placed in service in taxable years beginning after December 31, 2025. A California multifamily feasibility study states the bond request against this federal test and against the CDLAC award limits described above.
SBA eligibility and fiscal 2026 SBA approvals for California multifamily builders
Passive businesses owned by developers and landlords that do not actively use or occupy the assets acquired or improved with the loan proceeds are ineligible for SBA business loans (13 CFR 120.110(c), January 1, 2026 edition). The exception is an Eligible Passive Company under 13 CFR 120.111, which must lease to one or more Operating Companies under a written lease whose remaining term, including options to renew exercisable solely by the Operating Company, at least equals the loan term. Each holder of at least 20 percent of either company must guarantee the loan (13 CFR 120.111(a), same edition).
The SBA size standard for NAICS 531110, lessors of residential buildings and dwellings, is $34.0 million in annual receipts, and for NAICS 236116, new multifamily housing construction (except for-sale builders), it is $45.0 million (13 CFR 121.201, January 1, 2026 edition). A size standard measures whether a business is small, and it does not make an apartment lessor eligible.
Under NAICS 236116, 5 loans to California borrowers with $2,275,000 of gross approvals were approved in fiscal 2026, as recorded in the SBA 7(a) FOIA loan file as of September 30, 2026. Under NAICS 531110, the SBA 7(a) and 504 FOIA loan files as of the same date record no California approval in fiscal 2026. The files count every approval, including approvals later cancelled. A multifamily feasibility study in California names the programme that can carry each part of the debt before it tests coverage.
Frequently asked questions
How old can a market study be for a CTCAC or CDLAC application?
CTCAC requires a full market study prepared or updated within 180 days of the filing deadline (1). CDLAC requires an update when 180 days have elapsed between the earliest site inspection and the application deadline of the round, and will not accept an updated study once more than twelve months have passed since that inspection, when a new study is required (2).
Is there a capture rate limit in California?
The joint market study guidelines require a calculation of the capture rate for each income limit and of the penetration rate, and the December 2024 text we read prints no numeric ceiling for either (3). The tests that carry numbers are the 10 percent rent comparison and the lease-up to 95 percent occupancy within six or 12 months (1).
What DSCR does CTCAC require?
At least 1.15 to 1 in at least one of the first three years, except for FHA/HUD projects, RHS projects and projects financed with hard debt by the California Housing Finance Agency (1). Cash flow after debt service is also limited, to the higher of 25 percent of must pay debt service or 8 percent of gross income in each of those years (1).
How is property tax underwritten on a California tax credit deal?
At a minimum of 1 percent of total replacement cost, unless the verified rate is higher or lower, an identified 501(c)(3) corporate general partner will pursue an exemption, or the sponsorship includes a Tribe or tribally-designated housing entity (1). The exemption under the Board of Equalization's Rule 140 follows the share of the property's value in use by lower income households at restricted rents, and a limited partnership first obtains a Supplemental Clearance Certificate under Rule 140.2 (7)(8).
What guarantee fees does USDA charge on a Section 538 loan for rural California apartments?
A Rural Housing Service notice sets the standard reduced fee at 65 basis points initial and 35 basis points annual, effective September 30, 2026 (Federal Register, Docket RHS-26-MFH-0166). The fee is 60 and 25 basis points for workforce housing with rents between 80 and 115 percent of area median income, for preservation of existing Section 515 and 514/516 properties, and for new construction or substantial rehabilitation in Qualified Opportunity Zones.
Can Section 538 loan proceeds pay for commercial space in a rural California apartment project?
Only within limits. Loan proceeds may pay commercial space costs only where the space does not exceed 10 percent of the gross floor area of the residential units and common areas, unless the Agency approves a higher level in writing (7 CFR 3565.205, January 1, 2026 edition). The commercial income may not be more than 10 percent of total annual operating income. Neither limit is a general allowance for commercial space in a project.
Did federal law change the federal housing credit ceiling that funds California's 9 percent credits?
Yes, the federal ceiling. Public Law 119-21, section 70422(a), struck the multiplier 1.125 in Internal Revenue Code section 42(h)(3)(I) and inserted 1.12, a permanent 12 percent increase for calendar years beginning after December 31, 2025. For calendar year 2026 the ceiling is calculated on the greater of $3.416 multiplied by the state population or $3,953,600 (Internal Revenue Service, Rev. Proc. 2025-32, Section 4.08). CTCAC's table calls this amount the Federal Credit Ceiling, and it is not California's own state credit ceiling.
Do Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac limit how many apartment loans they buy in 2026?
Yes. The 2026 multifamily loan purchase caps are $88 billion for each Enterprise, $176 billion combined (U.S. Federal Housing news release on fhfa.gov, November 24, 2025). At least 50 percent of each Enterprise's multifamily business must be mission-driven affordable housing, and loans financing workforce housing are excluded from the 2026 limits.
Sources
This page summarises public rules for feasibility planning and is not legal advice.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, Regulations Implementing the Federal and State Low Income Housing Tax Credit Laws, California Code of Regulations, Title 4, Division 17, Chapter 1, December 10, 2025. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-03/regulations.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Regulations, December 10, 2025. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-03/approved.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee and California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Market Study Guidelines, December 2024. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2025-10/market-study-guidelines.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, Allocation Process for Set Asides and Geographic Regions, Estimated for Calendar Year 2026, updated September 2, 2026. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-03/2026-credit-estimates.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Exhibit A, Pool and Set-Aside Recommendation of 2026 State Debt Ceiling, updated as of September 14, 2026. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-09/Allocation_by_Round_9-14-2026.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, memorandum, 2026 Threshold Basis Limits, January 21, 2026. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-03/Threshold-Basis-Limits-Memo-2026_0.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California State Board of Equalization, Property Tax Rule 140, Welfare Exemption Requirements for Low-Income Housing Properties. https://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/rules/Rule140.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California State Board of Equalization, Property Tax Rule 140.2, Requirements for Supplemental Clearance Certificate for Limited Partnership. https://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/rules/Rule140_2.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California State Board of Equalization, Property Tax Rule 461, Real Property Value Changes. https://www.boe.ca.gov/proptaxes/pdf/rules/Rule461.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, memorandum, Proposed Regulation Changes with Initial Statement of Reasons, October 9, 2026 (proposal). https://treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/ctcac/CTCAC_2026_ISOR.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee and California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, memorandum, Proposed Changes to the Market Study Guidelines, October 30, 2026 (draft). https://treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/ctcac/2027_Market_Study_Guidelines-Memo_and_Proposed_Changes.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, memorandum, Draft 2027 Operating Expense Minimums, October 30, 2026 (draft). https://treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/ctcac/2027_Operating_Expense_Minimum_10-30-26.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, 2026 Application Information. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/ctcac/2026/application. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Final List of Awards, Qualified Residential Rental Projects, Round 1, June 22, 2026. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-09/QRRP_2026_Round_1_Final_Recommendation_List_of_Awards.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Final List of Awards, Qualified Residential Rental Projects, Round 2, September 1, 2026. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/2026-09/QRRP_2026_Round_2_Final_List_of_Awards.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, 2026 First Round 9% Final Approved Recommendations, June 22, 2026. https://treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/ctcac/2026_R1_Final_Recommendations.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, 2026 Second Round 9% Preliminary Recommendations, October 6, 2026 (preliminary). https://treasurer.ca.gov/sites/default/files/ctcac/2026_R2_Preliminary_Recommendations.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Department of Finance, E-1 population and housing estimates press release, May 1, 2026. https://dof.ca.gov/media/docs/forecasting/demographics/estimates/e-1_2026_press_release.Pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Department of Finance, E-5 Population and Housing Estimates for Cities, Counties and the State, 2020 to 2026, Table 1. https://dof.ca.gov/media/docs/forecasting/Demographics/estimates/e-5-population-and-housing-estimates-for-cities-counties-and-the-state-2020-2026/E-5_2026_InternetVersion.xlsx. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Tax Credit Allocation Committee, home page, 2025 Fast Facts. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/ctcac. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Department of Insurance, Stipulation and Order No. 2026-1, In the Matter of the California FAIR Plan Association, February 27, 2026. https://www.insurance.ca.gov/0250-insurers/0500-legal-info/0700-commissioners-orders/upload/FAIR-Plan-Stipulation-and-Order-No-2026-1.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Housing Finance Agency, Mixed-Income Program (2026) term sheet. https://www.calhfa.ca.gov/multifamily/mixedincome/forms/termsheet-mixedincome-2026.pdf. Read 2026-11-12.
- California Debt Limit Allocation Committee, Adopted and Proposed Regulations. https://www.treasurer.ca.gov/cdlac/regulations. Read 2026-11-12.
