Mid-2025 New York Multifamily Market Report: Low Vacancies, Rising Rents, and Strong Demand

88 Regent St - Jersey City, NJ 07302

New York’s multifamily housing market in mid-2025 is marked by record-low vacancy rates and record-high rents, underpinned by robust demand drivers and cautious but returning investor interest. Despite national softening in apartments, New York City’s rental market remains exceptionally tight – a critical trend for investors, developers, tenants, and lenders navigating current conditions. Vacancy rates in New York are hovering around just 2.8%-3.0%, far below the U.S. average of ~8%, and rents continue to climb to new peaks. Below, we delve into key facets of the market – from vacancies and rent growth to demand drivers, construction, and investment sales – using the latest data and insights (with references to charts and figures from the mid-2025 MMCG internal database) to paint a comprehensive picture.

Vacancy Rates: New York Remains Exceptionally Tight

New York’s apartment vacancy rate is astonishingly low by both historical and national standards. As of mid-2025, the metro-wide vacancy sits around 2.8%, compared to roughly 7-8% nationwide. This ultra-tight availability – roughly one-third of the national vacancy rate – signals a landlord’s market and underscores how demand far outstrips supply in the region. By submarket, the story is even more striking:

• Manhattan: Vacancy around the low-3% range (still very tight, even with new deliveries coming online). High demand in core neighborhoods keeps Manhattan’s rate below normal equilibrium.

• Brooklyn: Roughly in line with the metro average (~2.5-3%), despite accounting for a large share of new supply. Strong absorption in areas like Downtown Brooklyn and Williamsburg maintains low vacancies.

• Queens (inc. Long Island City): Under 2% – one of the lowest in the metro. Queens’ limited new supply in 2025 (relative to Brooklyn/Manhattan) and its growing renter base have pushed its vacancy rate below even the city’s average.

• The Bronx: Around 1% – effectively full occupancy. The Bronx has almost no excess inventory; demand is intense, and virtually every available unit is leased.

Even Northern New Jersey markets adjacent to NYC, like Jersey City, show low vacancies in prime buildings (on par with outer boroughs), as renters priced out of NYC proper still find limited options. Such across-the-board tightness is significant – at ~2.8%, the vacancy rates New York is experiencing are at or near historic lows, indicating powerful demand and insufficient supply. For context, a healthy balanced market might have 5% vacancy; New York is way below that. In practical terms, renters face intense competition for apartments, and landlords have little pressure to offer concessions. This dynamic also puts upward pressure on rents (discussed next) and gives developers confidence that new units will be quickly absorbed.

Rents at Record Highs and Still Rising

With vacancy so scarce, it’s no surprise that rents in New York are surging to new records. The current market rent New York landlords are asking has reached all-time highs in 2025. Metro-wide, the average asking rent is roughly $3,900+ per month – a figure that has inched up ~1% in the past quarter and 5-6% year-over-year. For perspective, the median asking rent for all NYC rentals hit about $3,397 in Q1 2025, up 5.6% from a year prior. By mid-2025, rents have only climbed further. This means New York remains one of the most expensive rental markets globally. A few highlights on rent New York trends:

• Manhattan: The priciest submarket saw rents jump ~5.5% year-over-year in early 2025. Manhattan’s median asking rent is now around $4,500, and the average 1-bedroom runs about $4,640 – up 8.4% YoY – with 2-bedrooms averaging a stunning $5,920 (nearly 20% YoY increase). High-end neighborhoods and luxury high-rises are pushing these record rents.

• Brooklyn: Brooklyn’s rents have risen ~5% YoY. The median rent in Brooklyn hit roughly $3,748 as of Q1 2025, with new luxury developments in areas like Downtown Brooklyn and Williamsburg commanding premium prices. Many Brooklyn neighborhoods now routinely see one-bedroom rents $3,000-$4,000, a staggering level historically, reflecting Brooklyn’s status as a preferred (and still slightly cheaper) alternative to Manhattan.

• Queens: Rents in Queens climbed about 4.3% YoY. In Long Island City (Queens’ prime rental enclave), new luxury towers have pushed average rents into the mid-$3,000s. Queens’ overall median (~$3,300) still undercuts Manhattan, but the gap has narrowed as Queens has urbanized and attracted more upscale development.

• Bronx: The Bronx saw only a modest ~0.7% rent uptick, with median rents around $3,000 in early 2025. Notably, Bronx rents had already soared in the last five years (over 40% since 2020), so the market there is catching its breath. The increasing rent New York tenants face is evident even in traditionally affordable areas – for many Bronx renters, rents are at or near their all-time highs, stretching affordability.

Overall, New York’s rents are rising faster than the national average. Nationwide, rent growth was roughly flat to +1% in early 2025, whereas New York posted around +5% YoY in asking rents. In fact, NYC rent increases have been among the strongest in the country this year. This divergence is fueled by the metro’s unique supply-demand imbalance. Renters in New York are now often paying 20-30% more than they did pre-pandemic for the same unit, erasing the pandemic rent dips entirely and then some. It’s important to note submarket variation: Manhattan rents are nearly 40-50% higher than Bronx rents, illustrating how location and product type matter. But virtually every corner of the metro – from Jersey City to Jamaica, Queens – is seeing high rent levels and year-over-year rent growth in mid-2025. For tenants, this means a heavier rent burden, and for owners, it means healthy revenue growth and pricing power not seen in years.

Demand Drivers: Jobs, Population Growth, and Cost of Ownership

What’s behind New York’s fierce demand for apartments? Several fundamental drivers are at play:

• Population Growth Resumes: After a dip in 2020-2021, New York City’s population is growing again. The city added about 87,000 residents between July 2023 and July 2024, bringing the population to approximately 8.48 million. All five boroughs saw gains, with Manhattan leading at +1.7% population growth. This return of people to the city – including young professionals and immigrants – has boosted apartment demand. Simply put, more people = more housing needed. The trend appears to be continuing into 2025 as the city recovers its vibrancy; Mayor Adams even heralded these figures as proof that “New York City is back”. A growing population in an already housing-constrained market puts downward pressure on vacancy and upwardpressure on rents.

• Record Job Market: The job market in New York is booming, reaching all-time highs in total employment. As of early 2025, New York City has record private-sector jobs, exceeding pre-pandemic levels. In March 2025, the region counted about 4.22 million private jobs (4.82M including government) – roughly +1.5% year-over-year growth. Crucially, many of these gains are in office-using and high-paying sectors (finance, tech, professional services). Companies like Apple and Amazon have expanded NY offices, adding high-income renters to the market. The return-to-office trend (net positive office absorption late last year) also signals that more employees are staying in or moving back to the city. Strong hiring, particularly of young professionals, directly translates to apartment demand – these workers often prefer renting in the city for flexibility and convenience. Additionally, 2025 saw New York implement congestion pricing in Manhattan’s core, which may further spur demand in transit-rich neighborhoods as commuters seek to avoid new driving costs. Overall, the healthy job market provides residents with income to pay rising rents and draws newcomers to the region.

• High Cost of Homeownership: New York’s homeownership hurdle is extremely high, forcing many to remain renters by necessity. The median price of a home in NYC is around $760,000 (as of 2023), and much higher in Manhattan. With today’s mortgage rates (~6-7%), the monthly payment on a median home can far exceed the cost of renting a comparable apartment. Moreover, a 20% down payment on a $760k home is over $150,000 – out of reach for most first-time buyers. Thus, a huge segment of the population that might elsewhere become homeowners is locked into renting in New York. In fact, the median renter age has climbed (now ~42 nationwide) as people rent longer, a trend clearly visible in NYC’s demographics. This affordability challenge – where the rent vs. buy calculus strongly favors renting – keeps demand for multifamily units robust. As long as buying a home in New York requires such steep income and savings, the rental market will benefit from a larger pool of lifelong renters. Additionally, tight credit and higher insurance/tax costs in the area further deter homeownership. In short, high home prices and high interest rates are funneling households into the rental market who in a cheaper market might have purchased homes.

Together, these factors create a potent demand engine. New York is effectively adding tens of thousands of renters each year between population gains and would-be buyers deferring ownership. At the same time, lifestyle preferences post-pandemic favor renting in urban hubs for many: people drawn by New York’s revived cultural and job opportunities but unwilling or unable to buy homes. Until either housing supply expands significantly or homeownership becomes more attainable (neither of which is on the immediate horizon), these drivers suggest that New York’s rental demand will remain elevated. This underpins the low vacancies and rising rents observed in 2025.

Construction Activity: New Supply Concentrated in Key Submarkets

On the supply side, new construction has picked up in certain New York submarkets, but remains relatively modest compared to demand – one reason vacancies stay low. Metro-wide inventory growth in 2025 is forecast under 1%, meaning the overall rental stock isn’t growing fast. However, the development that is happening is highly concentrated in a few areas:

• Brooklyn: Brooklyn is the epicenter of new development in the city. Nearly half of all new multifamily units coming online in 2025 are in Brooklyn In Q1 2025 alone, Brooklyn accounted for about 3,080 units (45% of NYC’s pipeline) in permit filings – leading all boroughs by far. Neighborhoods like Downtown Brooklyn, Williamsburg, and Park Slope/Gowanus are seeing a boom in high-rise apartment projects. Developers are attracted to Brooklyn’s relatively lower land costs (vs. Manhattan) and strong renter demand. The influx of supply is significant, but Brooklyn’s vacancy remains low, indicating these units are being absorbed. Commuter-friendly, amenity-rich projects in Brooklyn are catering to the metro’s fastest-growing renter base, as many tenants seek urban living at slightly less cost than Manhattan.

• Long Island City (Queens): Long Island City (LIC) has been a development hotbed for a decade and continues to deliver large projects. This waterfront Queens submarket, directly across from Midtown Manhattan, has several new luxury towers opening in 2024-2025, adding thousands of units. LIC’s draw is its proximity to Manhattan and an abundance of new construction with modern amenities. For example, a 50-story skyscraper The Italic with 363 units was completed recently, and other high-rises like Lumen LIC (opening spring 2025) are bringing hundreds more units. LIC’s pipeline remains strong, though Queens overall had fewer new permits than Bronx or Brooklyn this year. Still, Long Island City is emblematic of the high-density development filling New York’s housing gap – it has transformed into a vertical community of renters, helping Queens maintain low vacancies even as supply grows.

• Jersey City (Northern New Jersey): Across the Hudson, Jersey City has become an extension of NYC’s multifamily market. It’s one of the most active construction markets in the country. As of mid-2025, Northern New Jersey has roughly 27,000 units under construction, and Jersey City alone accounts for about one-third of those (≈9,000 units). That includes numerous high-rise towers near PATH train stations. For instance, a 54-story, 605-unit tower (“505 Summit”) topped out in Journal Square, and other towers like The Greyson (622 units) and the Artwalk Towers (595 units) are rising nearby. Over the past decade, apartment deliveries in Jersey City (and nearby Hoboken) rival Brooklyn and Queens, driven by commuter demand for luxury rentals with Manhattan skyline views. This has firmly positioned Jersey City as a major multifamily hub. However, it’s worth noting new construction starts in NJ have recently pulled back – only ~800 units started in the first five months of 2025, a 75% drop from the same period in 2024. This suggests that while many projects are under way, the pipeline is beginning to taper due to higher financing costs and a saturated short-term outlook. Even so, the thousands of units completing in 2025-2026 in Jersey City will provide some relief to the region’s supply crunch (and potentially draw some demand away from NYC boroughs).

• Suburban Markets: Beyond the city and immediate Jersey waterfront, suburban counties around New York are also adding multifamily housing, though typically mid-rise and smaller projects. In Westchester County (just north of NYC), cities have embraced transit-oriented development: for example, Yonkers has ~19,000 units of housing in its development pipeline (approved or under construction), and New Rochelle has about 6,400 units completed or actively being built in recent years – a dramatic expansion of housing stock for those cities. On Long Island and in northern New Jersey suburbs, developers are building new rental complexes near train stations to capture people who might work in the city but prefer suburban living. Notably, White Plains (a Westchester city) has nearly 2,000 units under construction currently and another ~2,400 in the approval process, according to local officials. These suburban projects collectively contribute thousands of units to the New York metro area. However, each individual suburb’s impact is modest compared to the city – no single town matches the scale of Brooklyn or Jersey City construction. Still, this trend indicates a regional push to expand housing supply, in line with demand spilling over city borders.

Outlook: Despite the pockets of construction activity, New York’s overall new supply remains limited relative to demand. The development cycle peaked nationally in 2022-23 and is now slowing, especially in high-cost markets like NYCm. Rising interest rates, the expiration of the 421-a tax abatement (now replaced by a more restrictive 485w/485x program), and high construction costs have made new projects harder to pencil out. Indeed, many developers are downsizing plans or pausing on large projects – evidenced by the shift toward smaller <100-unit buildings in NYC permits to avoid wage mandates. Analysts forecast that 2025’s housing completions in New York will be below recent peaks, which, combined with the demand drivers noted, should keep the market tight. Certain submarkets (Brooklyn waterfront, LIC, Jersey City) will see a wave of units – and thus potentially a slight easing of rent growth there – but citywide, no glut is on the horizon. If anything, the slight cooling of new starts now could lead to an even tighter market by 2026 once the current batch of projects is absorbed. For developers and investors, this supply backdrop suggests opportunity: projects that can get built and delivered in the next few years will face less competition and enter a vacancy-starved environment.

Investment Sales and Investor Sentiment

After a sluggish 2023, investment activity in New York’s multifamily sector has rebounded in 2025, though with a new mix of players and caution in underwriting. Sales volume has picked up significantly: in Q1 2025, NYC multifamily sales totaled about $2.21 billion, a 62% increase year-over-year. This suggests that buyer confidence is returning as the market outlook stabilizes. A few key points on the investment sales landscape:

• Free-Market Assets in Demand: Notably, free-market apartment buildings (i.e., largely without rent regulation) comprised 88% of the dollar volume in Q1 – a record high share. Investors are clearly favoring properties with unrestricted rents, given the 2019 rent law limits upside on rent-stabilized units. Sales of older rent-regulated walk-ups have slowed to a trickle, whereas newer luxury buildings or fully deregulated portfolios are trading actively. In fact, the surge in volume was led by major free-market deals in Manhattan and Brooklyn Top transactions included Steiner NYC’s $259.5 million acquisition of a multifamily portfolio (one of the largest post-pandemic deals in Brooklyn) and Ares Management’s $202.2 million purchase of an apartment asset. These big-ticket deals underscore renewed confidence in New York’s rental fundamentals – blue-chip investors are willing to deploy capital again, particularly for high-quality, well-leased assets. We also see local private groups aggressively buying, betting on long-term appreciation and rent growth.

• Private Capital Driving the Market: The buyer pool has shifted. Large institutions and REITs were mostly on the sidelines in 2023-24, but private investors (high-net-worth individuals, family offices, local operators) have stepped in to fill the void. CoStar reports and anecdotal evidence show well-funded private buyers snapping up properties – sometimes at prices below replacement cost, which they view as bargain opportunities. Many of these buyers have a longer-term horizon or a value-add strategy (e.g. capital upgrades to justify higher rents) and are less constrained by quarter-to-quarter performance than institutional funds. The result is a liquidity bifurcation: private capital is very active, while institutions wait for clearer signs of interest rate easing. In Q1 2025, the number of transactions in NYC actually rose about 5% year-on-year to ~269 deals, indicating more properties changing hands – mostly in the mid-market. Investor sentiment among these private players is cautiously optimistic; they believe “New York is still New York” – a supply-constrained market with enduring appeal – and are positioning themselves ahead of a full market recovery.

• Cap Rates and Values: Cap rate trends have been a central focus for investors. After rising throughout 2022-2023 alongside interest rates, cap rates appear to have plateaued in mid-2025. Across the U.S., multifamily cap rates leveled off in the mid-5% range by early 2025, and New York has followed suit to an extent. According to industry sources, typical NYC multifamily cap rates now average in the 5%–6% range (higher for walk-up buildings or outer borough garden apartments, lower for prime Manhattan assets). This is roughly 100+ basis points higher than the ultra-low cap rates (3.5%-4.5%) seen in 2021’s boom. The expansion in yields was necessary to accommodate higher borrowing costs. For example, some stabilized or older properties are trading at cap rates around 6-6.5% to attract buyers, whereas “core” luxury buildings in Manhattan might still trade closer to 4.5-5% due to their trophy status and rent growth potential. The good news is that pricing seems to have found a floor – bids and asks are coming closer now. Average per-unit prices citywide have largely stabilized after falling in 2022-23. In fact, some suggest values even bottomed out in late 2024 and have since inched up as competition for quality assets increases. With debt costs high, buyers are underwriting conservatively, but there’s a sense that the worst of the pricing correction is over.

• Investor Outlook: Sentiment is improving compared to last year. Part of this optimism is the expectation that interest rates may decline in late 2025 or 2026, which would boost values and lower financing costs. Indeed, many investors anticipate that if the Fed starts cutting rates, cap rates could begin to compress again (i.e. property values would rise). The rationale: New York’s fundamentals are strong (low vacancy, rising rents), so any relief on the financing side will likely drive renewed competition and higher pricing for assets. Some experts predict a “bullish” turn by next year – Marcus & Millichap’s forecast, for instance, hinted that cap rates might even dip slightly by year-end 2025 if rents keep climbing and borrowing costs ease. However, not all is rosy: the transaction recovery is uneven. Properties with heavy rent regulation or in need of major renovation still struggle to find buyers, and distress is a concern. There have been instances of owners defaulting on loans or selling at a loss, especially those who bought at peak prices with floating-rate debt. These distressed sales (or foreclosure auctions) could soften pricing in that segment of the market. But so far, distress hasn’t flooded the market – there’s not an oversupply of sellers, and many owners are holding through the high-rate period if they can. Overall, investor sentiment has shifted to cautious optimism. The phrase “selective opportunities” rings true: investors are cherry-picking deals – focusing on well-located, free-cash-flowing assets – and those deals are getting done at firmer prices. The New York multifamily market is on track for around $10 billion in sales in 2025 if current momentum continues, which would be a strong showing after the prior slowdown.

  
  

Conclusion and Outlook

As of mid-2025, New York’s multifamily market exhibits remarkable strength: vacancy rates at record lows, rents at record highs, and a demand engine fueled by population and jobs that shows no sign of abating. This has created a lucrative but challenging environment – great for owners and developers who can achieve top rents, but difficult for tenants facing affordability pressures. Investors are navigating a landscape where fundamentals are robust but the policy and interest rate environment requires care (e.g. rent regulations and financing costs). Looking ahead, the consensus is that New York will remain a landlord-favorable market through the rest of 2025. Even as thousands of new units come online in Brooklyn, Queens, Jersey City and beyond, they are likely to be met with eager renter demand. Barring an economic shock, vacancies should stay low (perhaps rising slightly if new supply momentarily outpaces absorption in a submarket or two), and rents are expected to keep increasing – New York simply has too much demand relative to supply constraints. Cap rates may start to compress if interest rates indeed fall, which would further boost property values and could trigger more investment activity and development plans.

For stakeholders – whether you’re an investor, developer, lender, or tenant – staying informed on these market conditions is crucial. High-level metrics like “vacancy rates New York” and “current market rent New York” give a snapshot of the tight conditions, but the nuance lies in submarket differences and emerging trends (like policy changes or construction pipelines). It’s an exciting time in the New York multifamily scene: the city’s rental market is dynamic and resilient, proving its attractiveness in the face of national headwinds.

MMCG’s role: In such a complex environment, expert analysis is invaluable. MMCG Invest, LLC stands out as a premier provider of feasibility studies and market research for multifamily development in the New York metro area, helping clients navigate these conditions with data-driven insight. Our mid-2025 report underscores the critical metrics and should serve as a guide for anyone looking to capitalize on opportunities or mitigate risks in New York’s multifamily market. With our deep local expertise, MMCG is ready to assist stakeholders in making informed decisions – whether it’s evaluating a development project’s viability, analyzing a potential acquisition, or understanding tenant demand in a given submarket. The New York multifamily market may be intense, but with the right information and partners, investors and developers can thrive in this city that so clearly “never sleeps” – especially when it comes to housing demand.

June 3, 2025 by Michal Mohelsky, J.D., principal of MMCG Invest, LLC, multi-family feasibility study consultant serving NYC

Sources:

• MMCG Internal datasets

• Stessa Rental Market Update (mid-2025) – National vs. NYC rent and vacancy trends

• Realtor.com NYC Rent Report Q1 2025 – Borough rent medians and growth rates

• NYC Mayor’s Office – Press release on population growth and record jobs (March 2025)

• Marcus & Millichap 2025 Forecast – Commentary on supply concentrations and demand drivers

• CRE Daily and Multi-Housing News – Construction pipeline figures and notable sales transactions

• Matthews Real Estate (Dec 2024) – Discussion on cap rate trends and pricing in NYC

• Ariel Property Advisors – Q1 2025 sales volume and transaction data

• Regional news (Real Estate In-Depth) – Suburban development pipeline highlights